ColorNews Issue #16

Color Management Myths 21-25

Welcome to ColorNews, a periodic update on things related to Color Management. We are striving for a regular consistent newsletter of high value to our customers. Please let us know what your interests are so we can address these concerns in our coming issues.


C H R O M i X C O L O R N E W S

Issue #16
December 22th, 2004


Happy Holidays!!!

There are many diverse things going on this month, and we would like to draw particular attention to these items:

** This month we announce the CHROMiX ColorForums.

** For those of you who were waiting for a price reduction of ProfileMaker v5 UPGRADE, GretagMacbeth has a 30% off sale until December 31st. See ad below for details.

** GretagMacbeth has just announced a completely NEW reconfiguration of the Eye-One Pro line-up. CHROMiX has made sense of it with a matrix we think you will find useful. See details below.

** The X-Rite Pulse ColorElite is now shipping!!! See details below.

** The X-Rite DTP-70 and DTP-45 and Monaco Profiler 4.7 are also shipping! See details below.

** Color Myths Continue, an article written by CHROMiX President Steve Upton


Table of Contents


1. CHROMiX News
2. Color, Product & Industry News
3. Shows and Events
4. Tech Notes: Photo File Formats and Workflow Automation
5. ColorFAQs - this month's FAQ is Color Myths Continue
6. CHROMiX USED items for sale
7. ColorNews Administration (feedback, subscriptions, etc.)




Since our last ColorNews Issue #15 (October 20th, 2004) many things have happened at CHROMiX that are worth mentioning:

CHROMiX ColorForums : This month we are very excited to announce the CHROMiX ColorForums. We've been working for months finding the right tools, configuring our server systems and setting things up just right. is the first full-featured online forum dedicated to color management tools, techniques and support. Not only is there a clear web-based interface to all forum topic areas but it is backed up with a comprehensive email system. You can read and post messages via the web or email, so those of you who don't always have time to surf the web can have the color management community come to you. So pay the ColorForums a visit when you have questions or just want to discuss color management.

CHROMiX is proud to announce the appointment of Anne Taylor as Director of Training and Consulting Services. Anne is a well-known prepress and printing veteran and was recently with Corbis setting worldwide imaging standards. Readers of previous ColorNews issues will recall that we've been working with Anne for a while now. Things have been going so well we decided we could really benefit by tapping her leadership skills. Expect to see more consulting and training offerings from us in the future.

Steve Upton is the featured speaker in a free QuickTime-based seminar sponsored by Apple and GretagMacbeth.
You can find it here (free registration required):
here. It is part of Apple's Color site, which is worth getting to know:

CHROMiX ColorThink Pro is extensively mentioned and used (for imagery) in Real World Color Management Edition 2. Thanks, Bruce and Chris, for the inclusion! CHROMiX ColorThink Pro is almost ready! Stay tuned, details to come very soon!!!

CHROMiX was at the recent GATF conference in Phoenix. Steve Upton and Anne Taylor gave presentations, sat on panels, helped plan events, and were generally seen whichever way you looked. Thanks to everyone who took the time to speak with Anne and Steve!

We want to thank our many CHROMiX Partner Program partners, who have helped make 2004 a great success. We would appreciate any comments as to how we might make 2005 even better. Please email your ideas to Rick Hatmaker at hatmaker(at) or call (866) CHROMiX ext. 7. We look forward to a very successful New Year with all of our Partners. Happy Holidays!

Did you know that CHROMiX ColorValet is the world's largest and most comprehensive PROFILING service? It's true!
Our ColorValet service has both end-user and OEM programs to fit your specific needs. If you're an organization, association, manufacturer or large end user, give us a call to discuss how we can customize a profiling program to meet your company's and/or customers' needs.
Call Rick Hatmaker at (866) CHROMiX or (866) 247-6649 ext 7.


Color, Product & Industry News


GretagMacbeth has almost completely re-configured the Eye-One line.
Here is a quick review of the new line up:
Eye-One Display2 Monitors (CRT & LCD) with new Match version 3.0 ($239)
Eye-One Design Monitors, RGB and CMYK in i1Easy mode and more ($795)
Eye-One Photo Monitors, RGB, CMYK (i1Easy mode only), Scanner, Digital
Projector, Digital Camera and Profile Editing and more ($1199)
Eye-One Proof Monitors, RGB (i1Easy mode only), CMYK, Scanner, Digital
Camera and Profile Editing and more ($1299)
Eye-One XT Monitors, RGB, CMYK, Scanner, Digital Projector, Digital Camera
and Profile Editing and more ($2295)

Eye-One Design and Eye-One Proof are completely new bundles. Eye-One XT replaces Eye-One Publish (which is gone). And Eye-One Photo has the same name but has added more components. The Camera and Editor modules will ship separately when released in early 2005. Shipping should be soon, so stay tuned. Also, CHROMiX will continue to include a FREE Eye-One Display with each Eye-One Bundle.

The Eye-One line is a little confusing, so CHROMiX has provided a simple matrix to help you understand the differences in the packages. You can find it here: here or give CHROMiX ColorGear Sales a call to discuss which one is right for you at 866-CHROMiX x1 or email sales(at)

GretagMacbeth released Eye-One Match 3.0 for Mac and Windows, an update to the application supplied with its Eye-One Display, Eye-One Design, Photo, Proof, XT and other Eye-One hardware packages. The improvements are significant, and version 2 owners can upgrade for free. For more information, go to: here

GretagMacbeth has fully implemented it's Eye-One iCare Program. iCare is a premium extended warranty and accuracy verification program for Eye-One Pro customers! The cost is $395 List and iCare can be purchased anytime within the standard warranty period.
Features include:
- 3 year extended warranty against manufacturer defects (unit includes one year standard warranty)
- Accidental damage protection for 3 years from time of purchase
- Eye-One carrying case
- Annual Accuracy Verification to ensure measurement quality each year
- 10% discount on all GretagMacbeth end-user training programs
Call us at 866-CHROMiX, x1, for more details on this great program.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
The PULSE is here!!
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
X-Rite is shipping the much acclaimed Pulse Color Elite System! This product is very aggressively priced and has been heralded by some as the next best thing for bringing Color Management to the masses. Shipments started December 13th and product is available at CHROMiX Sales.
The Pulse ColorElite System includes a new, precision handheld spectrophotometer (Pulse/DTP-20), an award-winning monitor calibrator (Optix XR/DTP-94), advanced color management software, the versatile Pathfinder hand-scanning guide, and an innovative storage unit.

Here is a link to view the different configurations and CHROMiX ColorGear prices:

And, if you've purchased Monaco EZ-Color, X-Rite is offering a $199 Trade-In rebate to Pulse Color Elite System for your Ez-Color.

For more information call CHROMiX sales at 866-CHROMiX extension 1.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
The DTP-70 is also here!!!
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
X-Rite has shipped the world's fastest scanning x-y spectrophotometer. The DTP-70 is so fast that you don't even have time to get a cup of coffee before it is done reading your target sheet! It reads a typical color target in less than three minutes and measures smaller targets for calibrating color proofing systems in just 30 seconds. And it's intelligent self-alignment feature virtually eliminates read errors. It is ideal for profiling RGB, CMYK, and up to 8-color output devices. Monaco Profiling software is the only compatible profiling software at the moment. The DTP-70 comes stand-alone or bundled with Monaco Profiler versions.
Call us at 866-CHROMix, x1 for more information

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Monaco PROFILER 4.7 is released
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
New enhancements include:
* Dramatically improved image detail in highlight, shadow and saturated color;
* Improved image contrast, producing more accurate results in proofing and cleaner, more natural color in perceptual rendering;
* Increased hue accuracy in saturated color reproduction;
* Increased neutral accuracy across the tonal scale.
Monaco PROFILER works with several X-Rite measurement instruments, including the Monaco Optix XR, the new DTP45 and the DTP70. In addition, the award-winning Monaco Optix XRPro software is now fully integrated into this package.
Available in two versions, the GOLD edition incorporate most advanced operational features. The Platinum edition adds Multi-color, Hexachrome and Digital Camera Target support. It is also available bundled with the X-Rite DTP41 Series II AutoScan Spectrophotometer.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
X-Rite DTP-45 ships!!!
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Yet another cool toy from X-Rite is the DTP-45, which is an automated, all-in-one prepress color measurement instrument for precise calibration, profiling and quality control. Features include:
* Detachable head for spot measurement
* L*a*b* display
* One-button operation
* On-board, storable calibration reference

Adobe announced an effort to standardize raw digital camera formats and will offer DNG spec as the standard format for storing raw files from multiple vendors' cameras. ColorNews had a previous mention of this item, but felt it was worth a second mention.


We found a great article worth your visit if you've ever wondered when to use JPEG, TIFF or RAW files generated from your digital camera: 'File Formats Made Easy', by JoAnne Carter
And you can find the link at:

One of the biggest challenges for Pro photographers using digital workflows is time they spent (or wasted) managing their digital photos. It can require many applications and resources to accomplish a task that is increasingly complex.

Extensis has an application called Portfolio v7, that helps photographers to streamline their workflow and automate many of the tasks that cut into their time behind the camera. Here is a downloadable PDF tech brief about it that's worth a read if this is your problem too:

Phase One also has a product called Capture One (or C1 for short) for photographers that addresses workflow and automation. There are Windows and Mac OS X versions 3.6 of C1 PRO, SE, LE 3.6. These applications are great image and workflow additions for digital SLR and compact cameras. Download a Mac demo at here




January 10 - 14, MacWorld San Francisco, CA. Everything for the Mac devoted. West Coast style.

February 20 - 23, PMA 2005 and DIMA 2005 Orlando, FL at the Orange County Convention Center in Orlando, Florida. For more information: here here

March 17-19, 2005 Graphic Arts 2005. Charlotte Convention Center, NC. This recent trade show and conference brings in thousands of industry professionals from the Southern USA. View many highlights of the 2003 show and sign up to be reminded of the next show in Charlotte, NC. here

May 23-26, 2005 Seybold New York. here
June 6-9, 2005 Seybold Amsterdam. here
September 11-14, 2005 Seybold Chicago. here
Nov 29 - Dec 2, 2005 Seybold San Francisco. here

September 9-15, 2005 PRINT '05 at McCormick Place Complex, Chicago, IL Because of its mammoth size and international presence, PRINT occurs only once every four years and will take the place of GRAPH EXPO and CONVERTING EXPO in 2005.


ColorFAQ - Color Myths Continue

Each issue, our President Steve Upton will take time to answer questions we receive on a regular basis. If you have specific questions or comments, please see below for how to make submissions.

As in previous ColorNews newsletters, there never seems to be an end to the myths and confusions we run across. This month I'll address 5 more.

Myth #21: There are perceptual rendering intents available when converting from scanner/camera->workspace or workspace->workspace.

First, a bit about non-colorimetric rendering intents and LUTs. Most monitor and RGB working spaces are made using simple Matrix profiles. Matrix profiles contain color measurements for the RGB channels, curves for each RGB channel and a white point tag. They are small, easy to store and totally depend on the device in question behaving very predictably. In the case of CRT monitors and working spaces, this is no problem.

However, when these matrix profiles are used in color conversions, the CMM has little choice of what to do with out-of-gamut colors. There are no instructions in a matrix profile regarding how to treat them. CMMs like the Adobe ACE CMM in Photoshop and other Adobe applications will simply "clip" out of gamut colors to the gamut of the destination. This is the relative colorimetric intent. The perceptual and saturation intents require more detailed instructions on how to treat out-of-gamut (and in-gamut) colors and these instructions are stored in 3D lookup tables (LUTs). So, matrix profiles are simple but can only do colorimetric conversions and LUT profiles can contain the more complicated instructions required by perceptual and saturation rendering.

See the problem yet?

Another point that needs to be made is that under version 2.x of the ICC spec (not the current spec but the one in wide use today) only one rendering intent is required in input profiles. What this means is that scanner and camera profiles are only required to contain one rendering intent's lookup table and that is the colorimetric one. They may contain additional tables but as they are not required, they are often not included.

Getting the picture? No?

In plain English this is what it means:

- when converting from workingspace to working space (say, Adobe RGB to sRGB), the ONLY rendering intent available is colorimetric. Photoshop allows you to select perceptual and saturation but they make NO difference (try it sometime). Photoshop should gray out intents that don't exist in the profiles.. but that's just my opinion....

- when converting from a scanner or camera profile to a working space the ONLY rendering intent available (in many cases) is relative colorimetric. Again, Photoshop will let you think you have others available but they are not contained in the profiles and choosing them will still give you relative colorimetric.

- as a result of these missing intents, you run the risk of clipping out-of-gamut colors AND because many of them are outside of your monitor's gamut you won't notice the problem until you go to print.

Joseph Holmes, a well-known and respected photographer and digital imaging fellow decided years ago that this was not what he wanted and he devised a strategy to get around the problem. His idea was to convert from an input profile to a large working space (and he invented his own, Ektaspace) and then archive the image in this form. When he was ready to go to print he would let the (actually existing) perceptual intent in the print profile shrink the gamut of the file in a pleasing way. This way he would bypass the potentially destructive scanner->smaller workingspace or workingspace->workingspace conversions. (he actually went

The ICC v4 specification allows for more intents in input profiles but there is no guarantee they will contain perceptual or saturation tables. Over the longer term though we should expect to see these tables in input profiles and we'll have a safer conversion path.

Matrix to matrix conversions, however, will always have this problem so be careful. Select your destination workingspace profile in "Proof Setup" and turn on gamut warning in Photoshop to see which colors in your image run the risk of getting clipped. Then either de-saturate colors by hand or leave your image in the larger working space and let the print profile shrink the gamut when required.

Myth #22: The a, b axis of Lab are red/green and blue/yellow.

The Lab color space as we know it today was created in 1976. The a and b axes are often described by people as the Red and Green axes but this is incorrect. (or at least unclear)

Try this test in Photoshop

- open Photoshop
- open the color picker
- enter the Lab color 100,-128,0 - this is the most negative "a" value
- look at the color that results - it appears cyan-ish

- now enter the Lab color 100,127,0 - this is the most positive "a" value
- look at the color that results - it appears magenta-ish

Sometimes when people write or speak about the Lab color space they describe the "a" axis as the red/green axis. As you can see by the above illustration it is better described as the magenta-ish / cyan-ish axis. These axes were chosen for their positioning relative to human perception NOT to make it easier for writers and speakers to describe them. It's easier to say "red/green" than "magenta-ish/cyan-ish" so many people do it. It's no big deal just don't panic when you discover that they're not actually red and green.

Myth #23: Photoshop's color setting dialog lets you edit an ICC CMYK profile.

This one's from a conversation I had with color management icon Don Hutcheson the other day.

There are two methods for setting up the CMYK working space and CMYK conversions in Photoshop and unfortunately Adobe has not made the distinction very clear so there's room for confusion.

First, the legacy CMYK system that has been around for many many versions is pre-ICC and is available when you choose "Custom CMYK..." in the CMYK popup of the Color Settings dialog. These CMYK setup options allow you to select ink color values, black generation, dot gain and other parameters. Once selected, Photoshop creates a simplified ICC profile that does not contain a paper white value and also only contains the colorimetric rendering intent.

Any other profile selected is a true ICC profile that is used by the Adobe ACE CMM to perform color transformations.

What's the difference? Well, the most important thing is that these are very different methods of setting up CMYK conversions and the older engine, while it has lots of options, produces conversions that are fairly crude and not up to today's standards. Another point is that the settings you see in the Custom CMYK setup area have NOTHING to do with the current or previous ICC profile. It's easy to get drawn into thinking that you can select a modern profile and then alter the profile's settings in the custom area. This is not the case however.

We urge you to use modern ICC profiles for your CMYK setup. if you feel you want to change the separation settings (which is understandable) then generate your own ICC profiles (in a profiling application) using your desired settings and then select them in Photoshop. Photoshop is not a profile editor and the only profiles it can generate are based on old technology and not enough color data to give quality results.

Myth #24: Working space selection in Photoshop affects profile building.

When creating a new print profile, often the first task is to print a profiling target from Photoshop. Whether you are creating an RGB or CMYK print profile the overall technique is the same. Open the target image file without performing any conversion. Then print the file without performing any conversion.

Get the idea? no conversion.

Some people are concerned about their choice of workingspace at the time of target printing. But, if you follow the path of no conversions then the workingspace is irrelevant. The only thing it will affect is the appearance of the target on screen. (for information regarding how confusing this can be, see Myth #11 in ColorNews Issue #13 ). Otherwise it has no bearing on the profile you build.

There is one case where it may make a difference. ColorVision's scanner-based profiling software makes certain assumptions about outgoing colors when it builds scanner-based print profiles. We don't recommend this method of print profiling as it doesn't measure up to professional quality and it also creates a profile that is dependent on the source color space which is... well.. strange at best, annoying, limiting and confusing at worst.

Myth #25: Device link profiles are limited, hard-coded versions of normal ICC transforms and are therefore redundant, inflexible and are to be avoided.

This one couldn't be further from the truth. But, again, I should start with a little background.

When you do a color conversion in Photoshop or other applications, the two profiles in question (say, US Sheetfed Coated and your inkjet profile) are joined together in RAM to form a single transformation. So, while the conversion theoretically goes from CMYK to Lab through the Sheetfed profile and then Lab to CMYK through your inkjet profile, in actuality the two profiles are joined in RAM and the conversion takes place as a single CMYK to CMYK transformation. This is pretty much transparent to you as a user but it does make the conversion faster and may also increase precision.

A device link profile is what you'd get if you were to save this combined profile to disk. It permanently links the profiles together using the selected rendering intent. The advantages of this are numerous:

- The CMM that was used to create the transformation contributes to the quality of the resulting device link profile. So you can use a good CMM on your desktop computer to create the link and then bypass the idiosyncrasies of the CMM on your RIP, for example.

- A normal device link does simply encapsulate a typical ICC color transformation including the tendency to reseparate K-only image elements into CMYK image elements. If this is undesirable (which it often is for re-separating CMYK files for alternate press conditions) then some software can filter the device link after it is created so that K-only color remains K-only after conversion. It will usually be tone corrected for the new profile but it will remain "clean". This is often called "preserve black" or "clean black".

- The same "clean" behavior can be applied to the other color channels. As each channel increases to 100% the other inks are minimized, maximizing the purity of the colors.

- An emerging technique is to use device link profiles to automate prepress-style edits. Curve bumps, ink limiting and other techniques can be captured in a device link profile and applied en-masse to large numbers of files in a color server or RIP. This can be a very powerful way of applying traditional channel-style edits in an ICC compliant workflow.

So, while device links are not widely supported (they are still not usable in Photoshop), they are powerful and can solve challenging color and production problems when needed. Keep an eye on technology that makes use of device link profiles. We have only seen the beginning of what they can do.

Thanks for reading, good luck in the new year.

Steve Upton
December 2004

For previous ColorNews articles follow this link:


To submit questions or feedback to CHROMiX, email us at colornews(at) Please include your name and email address in all correspondence (email, phone, fax etc).

To unsubscribe from CHROMiX ColorNews, reply to this message with "unsubscribe" in the subject.
To subscribe, email colornews(at) with "subscribe" in the subject.

Entire Contents of CHROMiX ColorNews (c)2004 CHROMiX, Inc.
CHROMiX, ColorThink, ColorNews, ColorSmarts, ColorGear, ColorForums and are trademarks of CHROMiX Inc.
All other trademarks are property of their respective owners.
CHROMiX ColorNews is intended as an informative update to CHROMiX customers and business associates. We are not responsible for errors or omissions.